Edward FitzGerald and "Posh", 
by James Blyth 
 
The Project Gutenberg eBook, Edward FitzGerald and "Posh", by 
James Blyth 
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with 
almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or 
re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included 
with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org 
 
Title: Edward FitzGerald and "Posh" "Herring Merchants" 
Author: James Blyth 
 
Release Date: February 8, 2007 [eBook #20543] 
Language: English 
Character set encoding: ISO-646-US (US-ASCII) 
***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK EDWARD 
FITZGERALD AND "POSH"*** 
 
Transcribed from the 1908 John Long edition by David Price, email 
[email protected]
EDWARD FITZGERALD AND "POSH" "HERRING MERCHANTS" 
INCLUDE A NUMBER OF LETTERS FROM EDWARD 
FITZGERALD TO JOSEPH FLETCHER OR "POSH," NOT 
HITHERTO PUBLISHED 
BY JAMES BLYTH 
WITH SIXTEEN ILLUSTRATIONS 
LONDON JOHN LONG NORRIS STREET, HAYMARKET 
MCMVIII 
Copyright by John Long, 1908 All Rights Reserved 
TO W. ALDIS WRIGHT, ESQ., M.A. VICE-MASTER OF TRINITY 
COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE I DEDICATE THIS SKETCH WITH 
MOST SINCERE THANKS FOR HIS INVALUABLE ASSISTANCE 
IN CONNECTION THEREWITH AND FOR HIS PERMISSION TO 
PRINT THE LETTERS OF EDWARD FITZGERALD WHICH ARE 
NOW PUBLISHED FOR THE FIRST TIME 
JAS. BLYTH 
March, 1908 
{"Posh" Fletcher in 1870. Taken for Edward FitzGerald: p0.jpg} 
 
PREFACE 
There can be no better foreword to this little sketch of one of the phases 
of Edward FitzGerald's life than the following letter, written to Thomas 
Carlyle in 1870, which was generously placed at my disposal by Dr. 
Aldis Wright while I was giving the sketch its final revision for the 
press. The portrait referred to in the letter is no doubt that reproduced 
as the photograph of 1870.
"DEAR CARLYLE, 
"Your 'Heroes' put me up to sending you one of mine--neither Prince, 
Poet, or Man of Letters, but Captain of a Lowestoft Lugger, and 
endowed with all the Qualities of Soul and Body to make him Leader 
of many more men than he has under him. Being unused to sitting for 
his portrait, he looks a little sheepish--and the Man is a Lamb with 
Wife, Children, and dumber Animals. But when the proper time 
comes--abroad--at sea or on shore--then it is quite another matter. And 
I know no one of sounder sense, and grander Manners, in whatever 
Company. But I shall not say any more; for I should only set you 
against him; and you will see all without my telling you and not be 
bored. So least said soonest mended, and I make my bow once more 
and remain your 
"Humble Reader, "E. FG." 
Too much has been made by certain writers, with more credulity than 
discretion, of some personal characteristics of a great-hearted man. My 
purpose in tendering this sketch to the lovers of FitzGerald is to show 
that in many ways he has been calumniated. The man who could write 
the letters to his humble friend, which are here printed; the man who 
could show such consistent tenderness and delicacy of spirit to his 
fisherman partner, and could permit the enthusiasm of his affection to 
blind him to the truth, was no sulky misanthrope; but a man whose 
heart, whose intensely human heart, was so great as to preponderate 
over his magnificent intellect. Edward FitzGerald was a great poet, and 
a great philosopher. He was a still greater man. 
Therefore, my readers, if, during the perusal of these few letters, you 
"in your . . . errand reach the spot"--whether it be at Woodbridge, 
Lowestoft, or in that supper-room in town "Where he made one"--". . . 
turn down an empty glass" to his memory. 
For there is no Saki to do it, either here or with the houris. 
JAMES BLYTH
INTRODUCTION 
Towards the end of the summer of 1906 I received a letter from Mr. F. 
A. Mumby, of the Daily Graphic, asking me if I knew if Joseph 
Fletcher, the "Posh" of the "FitzGerald" letters, was still alive. All 
about me were veterans of eighty, ay, and ninety! hale and garrulous as 
any longshoreman needs be. But it had never occurred to me before that 
possibly the man who was Edward FitzGerald's "Image of the Mould 
that Man was originally cast in," the east coast fisherman for whom the 
great translator considered no praise to be too high, might be within 
easy reach. 
My first discovery was that to most of the good people of Lowestoft the 
name of the man who had honoured the town by his preference was 
unknown. A solicitor in good practice, a man who is by way of being 
an author himself, asked me (when I named FitzGerald to him) if I 
meant that FitzGerald who had, he believed, made a lot of money out 
of salt! A schoolmaster had never heard of either FitzGerald or Omar.