Critical Miscellanies, Vol. I

Critical Miscellanies, Vol. I, by
John Morley

The Project Gutenberg EBook of Critical Miscellanies, Vol. I, by John
Morley This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and
with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away
or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included
with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.net
Title: Critical Miscellanies, Vol. I Essay 2: Carlyle
Author: John Morley
Release Date: March 22, 2007 [EBook #20878]
Language: English
Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1
*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK CRITICAL
MISCELLANIES, VOL. I ***

Produced by Paul Murray, Janet Blenkinship and the Online
Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net

CRITICAL MISCELLANIES
BY

JOHN MORLEY
VOL. I.
ESSAY 2: CARLYLE
London MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED NEW YORK: THE
MACMILLAN COMPANY 1904

CONTENTS
Mr. Carlyle's influence, and degree of its durability 135
His literary services 139
No label useful in characterising him 142
The poetic and the scientific temperaments 144
Rousseau and Mr. Carlyle 147
The poetic method of handling social questions 149
Impotent unrest, and his way of treating it 152
Founded on the purest individualism 154
Mr. Carlyle's historic position in the European reaction 157
Coleridge 159
Byron 161
Mr. Carlyle's victory over Byronism 163
Goethe 164
Mr. Carlyle's intensely practical turn, though veiled 166

His identification of material with moral order 169
And acceptance of the doctrine that the end justifies the means 170
Two sets of relations still regulated by pathological principle 172
Defect in Mr. Carlyle's discussion of them 174
His reticences 176
Equally hostile to metaphysics and to the extreme pretensions of the
physicist 177
Natural Supernaturalism, and the measure of its truth 179
Two qualities flowing from his peculiar fatalism:-- (1) Contempt for
excess of moral nicety 182 (2) Defect of sympathy with masses of men
186
Perils in his constant sense of the nothingness of life 188
Hero-worship, and its inadequateness 189
Theories of the dissolution of the old European order 193
Mr. Carlyle's view of the French Revolution 195
Of the Reformation and Protestantism 197
Inability to understand the political point of view 199

CARLYLE.
The new library edition of Mr. Carlyle's works may be taken for the
final presentation of all that the author has to say to his contemporaries,
and to possess the settled form in which he wishes his words to go to
those of posterity who may prove to have ears for them. The canon is
definitely made up. The golden Gospel of Silence is effectively

compressed in thirty fine volumes. After all has been said about
self-indulgent mannerisms, moral perversities, phraseological outrages,
and the rest, these volumes will remain the noble monument of the
industry, originality, conscientiousness, and genius of a noble character,
and of an intellectual career that has exercised on many sides the
profoundest sort of influence upon English feeling. Men who have long
since moved far away from these spiritual latitudes, like those who still
find an adequate shelter in them, can hardly help feeling as they turn
the pages of the now disused pieces which they were once wont to
ponder daily, that whatever later teachers may have done in definitely
shaping opinion, in giving specific form to sentiment, and in subjecting
impulse to rational discipline, here was the friendly fire-bearer who
first conveyed the Promethean spark, here the prophet who first smote
the rock.
That with this sense of obligation to the master, there mixes a less
satisfactory reminiscence of youthful excess in imitative phrases, in
unseasonably apostolic readiness towards exhortation and rebuke, in
interest about the soul, a portion of which might more profitably have
been converted into care for the head, is in most cases true. A hostile
observer of bands of Carlylites at Oxford and elsewhere might have
been justified in describing the imperative duty of work as the theme of
many an hour of strenuous idleness, and the superiority of golden
silence over silver speech as the text of endless bursts of jerky rapture,
while a too constant invective against cant had its usual effect of
developing cant with a difference. To the incorrigibly sentimental all
this was sheer poison, which continues tenaciously in the system.
Others of robuster character no sooner came into contact with the world
and its fortifying exigencies, than they at once began to assimilate the
wholesome part of what they had taken in, while the rest falls gradually
and silently out. When criticism has done its just work on the
disagreeable affectations of many of Mr. Carlyle's disciples, and on the
nature of Mr. Carlyle's opinions and their worth as specific
contributions, very few people will be found to deny that his influence
in stimulating moral energy, in kindling enthusiasm for virtues worthy
of enthusiasm, and in stirring