Gunmans Reckoning

by Max Brand
1921
1
The fifty empty freights danced and rolled and rattled on the rough road bed and filled
Jericho Pass with thunder; the big engine was laboring and grunting at the grade, but five
cars back the noise of the locomotive was lost. Yet there is a way to talk above the noise
of a freight train just as there is a way to whistle into the teeth of a stiff wind. This
freight-car talk is pitched just above the ordinary tone--it is an overtone of conversation,
one might say--and it is distinctly nasal. The brakie could talk above the racket, and so, of
course, could Lefty Joe. They sat about in the center of the train, on the forward end of
one of the cars. No matter how the train lurched and staggered over that fearful road bed,
these two swayed in their places as easily and as safely as birds on swinging perches. The
brakie had touched Lefty Joe for two dollars; he had secured fifty cents; and since the
vigor of Lefty's oaths had convinced him that this was all the money the tramp had, the
two now sat elbow to elbow and killed the distance with their talk.
"It's like old times to have you here," said the brakie. "You used to play this line when
you jumped from coast to coast."
"Sure," said Lefty Joe, and he scowled at the mountains on either side of the pass. The
train was gathering speed, and the peaks lurched eastward in a confused, ragged
procession. "And a durned hard ride it's been many a time."
"Kind of queer to see you," continued the brakie. "Heard you was rising in the world."
He caught the face of the other with a rapid side glance, but Lefty Joe was sufficiently
concealed by the dark.
"Heard you were the main guy with a whole crowd behind you," went on the brakie.
"Yeh?"
"Sure. Heard you was riding the cushions, and all that."
"Yeh?"
"But I guess it was all bunk; here you are back again, anyway."
"Yep," agreed Lefty.
The brakie scratched his head, for the silence of the tramp convinced him that there had
been, after all, a good deal of truth in the rumor. He ran back on another tack and slipped

about Lefty.
"I never laid much on what they said," he averred. "I know you, Lefty; you can do a lot,
but when it comes to leading a whole gang, like they said you was, and all that--well, I
knew it was a lie. Used to tell 'em that."
"You talked foolish, then," burst out Lefty suddenly. "It was all straight."
The brakie could hear the click of his companion's teeth at the period to this statement, as
though he regretted his outburst.
"Well, I'll be hanged," murmured the brakie innocently.
Ordinarily, Lefty was not easily lured, but this night he apparently was in the mood for
talk.
"Kennebec Lou, the Clipper, and Suds. Them and a lot more. They was all with me; they
was all under me; I was the Main Guy!"
What a ring in his voice as he said it! The beaten general speaks thus of his past triumphs.
The old man remembered his youth in such a voice. The brakie was impressed; he
repeated the three names.
"Even Suds?" he said. "Was even Suds with you?"
"Even Suds!"
The brakie stirred a little, wabbling from side to side as he found a more comfortable
position; instead of looking straight before him, he kept a side-glance steadily upon his
companion, and one could see that he intended to remember what was said on this night.
"Even Suds," echoed the brakie. "Good heavens, and ain't he a man for you?"
"He was a man," replied Lefty Joe with an indescribable emphasis.
"Huh?"
"He ain't a man any more."
"Get bumped off?"
"No. Busted."
The brakie considered this bit of news and rolled it back and forth and tried its flavor
against his gossiping palate.
"Did you fix him after he left you?"
"No."

"I see. You busted him while he was still with you. Then Kennebec Lou and the Clipper
get sore at the way you treat Suds. So here you are back on the road with your gang all
gone bust. Hard luck, Lefty."
But Lefty whined with rage at this careless diagnosis of his downfall.
"You're all wrong," he said. "You're all wrong. You don't know nothin'."
The brakie waited, grinning securely into the night, and preparing his mind for the story.
But the story consisted of one word, flung bitterly into the rushing air.
"Donnegan!"
"Him?" cried the brakie, starting in his place.
"Donnegan!" cried Lefty, and his voice made the word into a curse.
The brakie nodded.
"Them that